Einstein and the professor
Page 4 of 5
Analyzing the story:
In the third last paragraph, “Einstein” says: “Evil is simply the absence of God.” Note that “Einstein” first assumes the existence of God in order to prove the existence of God. He is saying that God exists and thus God exists. This is circular reasoning, and makes his analysis meaningless. | ||||
The story attempts to prove God’s existence as follows:
|
However, an alternate initial statement would be that “Evil is simply the absence ofgood.” I suspect that if you asked many people what the antonym of “evil” is, the vast majority would respond “good.” Very few would respond “God.”
By substituting “good” for “God,” the argument collapses.
Another approach would be to realize that no consensus exists over what is good and evil in a given situation.
|
||||
There are obviously very different views of good and evil in the world. Most individuals probably believe that absolute truth exists for them, and perhaps even for their culture and religious denomination or tradition. But when comparing the absolute truths as claimed by different individuals, cultures, and denominations, we observe great diversity and much mutual exclusivity. There is no agreement on what is good and what is evil.If we equate goodness with God, as was done in this story, then it is obvious that a multiplicity of Gods would have to exist. This would not be difficult during ancient times when different Gods and Goddesses were assumed to be in charge of different cultures. However, the argument collapses if one is trying to prove that only a single deity exists. |
Einstein: His Life and Universe...
View
Einstein and the Theory of Relativity...
View
Einstein's Universe...
View
Moonwalking with Einstein: The Art and Science of ...
View
Sock It To Me Men's Einstein Relatively Cool ...
View
- Ultra soft, high quality, Einstein socks
- Our threads are certified by OEKO-TEX Standard 100, which means we leave out harmful chemicals to keep your skin safe and happy
- Approximately fits men's shoe size 7-13
- Ideal for the nerdy, geeky, engineer, scientist, mathematician, computer coder, electrician
- STYLISH, COMFORTABLE, STRETCHY - Your toes will be cozy in these eye-catching, thick, comfy socks
Baby Santa's Music Box Part 1...
View
Max Einstein: The Genius Experiment (Max Einstein,...
View
Einstein and Eddington...
View
Einstein's God Model...
View
Ideas And Opinions...
View
Who was Albert Einstein A Documentary...
View
Baby Einstein Baby Beethoven - Symphony of Fun...
View
When Einstein Walked with Gödel: Excursions to th...
View